Talk:Jigsaw (Zine): Difference between revisions
→Requirements: new section |
→Notes: new section |
||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
# Citations in MLA format that point to the sources you used in your research - links don't work | # Citations in MLA format that point to the sources you used in your research - links don't work | ||
# Add the page to the category "Riot Grrrl Zines" - not done | # Add the page to the category "Riot Grrrl Zines" - not done | ||
== Notes == | |||
''Intro'' - Good basic information. | |||
''Summary'' - Interesting summary of the theme of the zine. How is this information communicated in the zine itself? It would be helpful to understand more about the format, such as how many pages it is and what kind of type or text it contains. Is it a part of a series? | |||
''References and promotions'' - Interesting list. How are these referred to in the zine? Are they advertisements? This list could use more explanation, especially why you felt it was important to include. | |||
''Category'' - I had a difficult time locating the page, because it wasn’t included in the Riot Grrrl Zines category. | |||
''Images'' - You included the cover. I would love to see details of the pages. | |||
''Citations'' - Inconsistent use of citations, and they are not provided in MLA format. | |||
''Author Bio'' - Ok, brief biography of the creator of the zine. Kathleen Hanna is also included as a co-creator, but it’s the first time she is mentioned. Would have been nice to be introduced to her role earlier in the article. | |||
Latest revision as of 11:53, 24 September 2025
Requirements
- Title, year, and location of the publication - done
- Images of the zine - just the cover
- Summary of the zine's content - say more about the zine's format and that it is a part of a series
- Biography of the zine's author(s)/editor(s) - could be more in depth, especially since these are key figures and there is a lot of information available about them
- Background of the Riot Grrrl movement, especially as it relates to the zine that is the topic of your article. (In other words, give the zine context). - could say more about Jigsaw’s place in riot grrrl
- Citations in MLA format that point to the sources you used in your research - links don't work
- Add the page to the category "Riot Grrrl Zines" - not done
Notes
Intro - Good basic information.
Summary - Interesting summary of the theme of the zine. How is this information communicated in the zine itself? It would be helpful to understand more about the format, such as how many pages it is and what kind of type or text it contains. Is it a part of a series?
References and promotions - Interesting list. How are these referred to in the zine? Are they advertisements? This list could use more explanation, especially why you felt it was important to include.
Category - I had a difficult time locating the page, because it wasn’t included in the Riot Grrrl Zines category.
Images - You included the cover. I would love to see details of the pages.
Citations - Inconsistent use of citations, and they are not provided in MLA format.
Author Bio - Ok, brief biography of the creator of the zine. Kathleen Hanna is also included as a co-creator, but it’s the first time she is mentioned. Would have been nice to be introduced to her role earlier in the article.
